Contingencies in Real Estate - What is a Contingent Real Estate Listing?

Navigating the real estate market for the first time can feel like trying to decipher a foreign language. One term you’ll often come across is “contingency.” Understanding contingencies is crucial for both buyers and sellers because they can significantly impact the outcome of a real estate transaction. Whether you’re scrolling through listings or sitting down with your real estate agent, you’ll encounter properties marked as contingent. But what does that really mean?

In the simplest terms, a contingent real estate listing indicates that an offer has been made and accepted, but the final sale depends on certain conditions being met. Contingent means that these conditions must be satisfied before the sale can be finalized. These conditions, known as contingencies, protect both buyers and sellers, ensuring that specific criteria are satisfied before the transaction is finalized. This could be anything from securing financing to passing a home inspection.

For first-time homebuyers, especially those who get most of their information from TikTok, Instagram Reels, or YouTube, understanding the ins and outs of contingencies can seem overwhelming. That’s why we’re breaking it down in this blog. We’ll cover what a contingent real estate listing is, the different types of contingencies you might encounter, and how they can affect your home-buying or selling journey. By the end, you’ll be well-equipped to navigate these waters with confidence and make informed decisions every step of the way.

What is a Contingent Real Estate Listing?

A contingent real estate listing is one where an offer has been made and the seller has accepted it, but the sale is not yet final because it depends on certain conditions being met. These conditions, known as contingencies, act as safety nets for both buyers and sellers, ensuring that specific criteria are satisfied before the deal can go through. Contingencies can cover a range of factors, from financing and inspections to the sale of another property.

When you see a property listed as contingent, it means that while an offer is in place, the transaction is still in a sort of limbo, known as contingent status. The property is technically off the market, but it could return if the contingencies are not met within the agreed-upon timeframe. This stage is crucial because it provides both parties with a level of security and a way to back out of the deal without significant penalties if things don’t go as planned.

The importance of understanding contingent listings cannot be overstated, especially for first-time buyers and sellers. Contingencies are quite common in real estate transactions, with approximately 40% of home sales including some form of contingency. This statistic highlights the necessity of being well-versed in what these terms mean in real estate, and how they can affect your real estate journey.

Contingencies offer a layer of protection. For instance, a financing contingency allows buyers to back out if they cannot secure a mortgage. Similarly, an inspection contingency can help buyers negotiate repairs or even walk away from the deal if significant issues are found. These safeguards are designed to ensure that both parties are satisfied and protected before the final handshake.

By understanding what a contingent real estate listing is and how it functions, you can approach your real estate transactions with greater confidence and clarity. This knowledge will help you navigate the complexities of the market and make more informed decisions, ultimately leading to a smoother and more successful buying or selling experience.

Types of Contingencies

When diving into the world of real estate, understanding the various types of contingencies and the role of a contingency clause can provide you with the knowledge needed to navigate transactions with confidence. Contingencies are conditions that must be met for a real estate deal to proceed. They act as safeguards, ensuring that both buyers and sellers are protected throughout the transaction. Here’s a breakdown of the most common types of contingencies you’re likely to encounter.

Financing Contingency

A financing contingency is one of the most critical protections for homebuyers, as it stipulates that the buyer must secure financing, typically a mortgage, within a specified period. If the buyer cannot obtain financing, they can back out of the deal without losing their earnest money deposit. This contingency is essential because it ensures that buyers are not forced into a sale they cannot afford.

• Protects buyers from financial risk.
• Provides a timeframe to secure a mortgage.
• Allows buyers to walk away if financing falls through.

Inspection Contingency

An inspection contingency, also known as a home inspection contingency, allows the buyer to have the property professionally inspected before finalizing the purchase agreement. This contingency is crucial for identifying any potential issues with the home, from structural problems to pest infestations. If significant issues are discovered, the buyer can negotiate repairs, request a price reduction, or even cancel the contract.

• Ensures the property is in good condition.
• Allows for renegotiation based on inspection results.
• Provides an exit strategy if major issues are found.

Appraisal Contingency

The appraisal contingency protects the buyer by ensuring that the property’s value is assessed by a professional appraiser. If the home appraises for less than the agreed upon purchase price, the buyer can renegotiate the price or walk away from the deal. This contingency is vital because it prevents buyers from overpaying for a property.

• Ensures the property is worth the purchase price.
• Protects buyers from overpaying.
• Allows for renegotiation or cancellation if the appraisal is low.

Home Sale Contingency

A home sale contingency is often used by buyers who need to sell their current home to finance the purchase of a new one. This contingency states that the sale is dependent on the buyer successfully selling their existing property. While this can be a critical safety net for buyers, it can also make their offer less attractive to sellers who may prefer a deal with fewer contingencies.

• Provides time for buyers to sell their current home.
• Prevents buyers from owning two homes simultaneously.
• Can be a drawback in competitive markets.

Title Contingency

The title contingency protects the buyer by ensuring that the property has a clear title. This means there are no legal claims or liens against the property that could affect ownership. A title search is conducted, and if any issues are found, the buyer can request that they be resolved before closing or cancel the contract.

• Ensures clear ownership of the property.
• Protects against legal issues with the title.
• Allows buyers to exit the deal if title problems are unresolved.

Insurance Contingency

An insurance contingency requires the buyer to obtain homeowners insurance for the property. This contingency ensures that the prospective buyer can secure insurance, which is often a requirement for mortgage approval. If the buyer cannot get insurance, they can withdraw from the sale.

• Ensures the property can be insured.
• Necessary for mortgage approval.
• Allows buyers to back out if insurance is unattainable.

Pros and Cons of Contingent Listings

Contingent listings are a common feature in the real estate market, and understanding their advantages and disadvantages is crucial for both buyers and sellers, especially prospective buyers. These listings can offer significant protections and opportunities, but they also come with potential drawbacks that should be carefully considered. Here’s a detailed look at the pros and cons of contingent listings.

Pros for Buyers

Protection and Security

One of the primary benefits of making a contingent offer is the protection it provides. Contingencies act as safety nets, allowing buyers to back out of a deal without losing their earnest money if certain conditions aren’t met. This reduces financial risk and provides peace of mind.

• Financial Contingency: Ensures that the buyer can secure a mortgage before committing to the purchase.
• Inspection Contingency: Allows buyers to confirm the property’s condition and negotiate repairs or price reductions if issues are found.
• Appraisal Contingency: Protects buyers from overpaying by ensuring the property’s value matches the agreed-upon price.

Flexibility

Contingent offers provide buyers with the flexibility to address potential issues without being locked into a contract, making real estate contingencies for buyers a crucial aspect of the home-buying process. This can be especially important in a competitive market where making a quick decision might lead to overlooking significant problems.

Cons for Buyers

Potential to Lose the Property

One of the main drawbacks of making a contingent offer is the possibility of losing the property to another buyer. Sellers might prefer non-contingent offers that promise a quicker, more straightforward closing process. Contingent listings can make a property seem less appealing, potentially leading to missed opportunities.

Extended Closing Process

Contingencies can lengthen the closing process as each condition needs to be met and verified before the property can move to pending status. This can be frustrating for buyers eager to move into their new home quickly. The additional time required to satisfy contingencies can delay the transaction significantly.

Pros for Sellers

Attracts Serious Buyers

Contingent offers often come from serious buyers who are committed to purchasing the property, assuming their conditions are met. These buyers are typically more engaged and prepared to move forward once the contingencies are resolved.

Negotiation Opportunities

Sellers can use contingencies to their advantage by negotiating terms that are favorable to them. For example, they might agree to a contingency that allows them to remain in the home for a certain period after closing, providing flexibility in their own home search.

Cons for Sellers

Uncertainty and Risk

One of the primary disadvantages for sellers is the uncertainty that comes with contingent offers. Until the contingencies are met, the deal isn’t guaranteed. This uncertainty can be stressful, especially if the seller needs to sell quickly or has already committed to purchasing another property.

Potentially Fewer Offers

Properties listed as contingent may receive fewer offers since some buyers and their agents might avoid homes with pending conditions. This can reduce the overall pool of potential buyers and might lead to a longer time on the market.

Extended Time on Market

Contingencies can prolong the time a property stays on the market, which might be detrimental in a competitive real estate environment. If contingencies aren’t met promptly, the deal can fall through, forcing the seller to relist the property and start the process over.

How to Handle Contingencies

Handling contingencies effectively is crucial for ensuring a smooth real estate transaction. While contingencies provide necessary protections, managing them requires strategic thinking and proactive measures. Here’s how both buyers and sellers can handle contingencies to their advantage.

Negotiating Contingencies

For Buyers

When negotiating contingencies in a contingent real estate contract, clarity and specificity are your best friends. Vague or open-ended contingencies can lead to misunderstandings and delays. Be explicit about the conditions and timeframes. For example, if you’re adding an inspection contingency, specify the exact period for the inspection and response. This not only sets clear expectations but also keeps the process moving smoothly.

• Be Specific: Detail the conditions and timeframes for each contingency.
• Prioritize: Focus on the most critical contingencies to avoid overcomplicating the offer.
• Communicate Clearly: Ensure all terms are clearly understood by both parties.

For Sellers

Sellers should review contingencies carefully and negotiate terms that protect their interests while remaining attractive to other prospective buyers. Consider setting limits on repair costs or requesting that only significant issues be addressed. This approach can prevent minor repairs from becoming deal-breakers and keep the transaction on track.

• Set Limits: Define what constitutes a significant repair.
• Be Flexible: Offer solutions or compromises that can satisfy both parties.
• Stay Informed: Understand each contingency’s implications to make informed decisions.

Managing Contingency Periods

For Buyers

Once contingencies, such as a mortgage contingency, are in place, managing them efficiently is essential. Keep a close eye on deadlines and ensure all necessary actions are completed within the agreed timeframe. For instance, schedule inspections and appraisals promptly to avoid delays. Staying organized and proactive can prevent last-minute surprises and ensure a smooth process.

• Stay Organized: Keep track of all deadlines and necessary actions.
• Act Promptly: Schedule inspections, appraisals, and other required activities as soon as possible.
• Communicate Regularly: Keep in touch with your agent and the seller to update them on progress.

For Sellers

Sellers should also be proactive in managing contingencies. Stay in close communication with your agent and be prepared to act quickly if issues arise. For example, if an inspection reveals significant problems, have a plan in place to address them promptly. Quick responses can prevent the deal from falling through and demonstrate your commitment to the transaction.

• Be Proactive: Address issues as soon as they arise.
• Have a Plan: Be prepared to negotiate or make repairs quickly if needed.
• Maintain Communication: Keep the lines of communication open with the buyer and your agent.

Real Example Played Out At Odigo Real Estate Club

Contingency For A Seller

One example of how a contingency affected my seller is through an appraisal contingency.

If the buyer gets an appraisal on the home they are in contract with the seller, they typically have a financing contingency, one of two main contingencies that has within it the appraisal contingency.

If the appraisal comes in lower than what the contracted price is, then the buyer has the ability to be able to cancel the contract and refund their earnest money or good faith money.

When the market was hot, a lot of appraisals came in low due to the fact that prices were going up so rapidly, the data to prove the value of the home which is pulled from 6 months of historical comparables sold in the area did not match up to the high price that sellers were selling.

So the seller has two choices in this matter.

Either lower the price to the appraised price, the buyer can put more down payment to cover the difference, or allow the buyer to walk away from the deal.

In our situation, I actually reached out to the various other buyers who lost the multiple bidding war on my seller's property and asked them if they would essentially match the price of the currently contracted price.

Then I would use the competing buyer's offer as leverage to get the current buyer to simply put more down payment into the home, effectively utilizing a kick out clause. That is exactly what happened in the transaction.

Contingency For A Buyer

The main contingency for a buyer in a past transaction is through the inspection contingency.

In an inspection contingency, you are not obligated to do an actual inspection.

For whatever reason, you can use this contingency to back out of the transaction and retrieve your earnest money.

We typically include a inspection contingency with all of our offers. Not only to have a means to back out but to use the inspection and all of the problems they find, to leverage and negotiate a lower price, a seller credit to your closing costs, or to fix items.

We've been able to negotiate 6 figures of credits/discounts to the price by using a very thorough inspector to generate a detailed report of all of the problems of the home.

Then we would expose a lot of these issues to the seller and leverage that to get a large discount.

Most agents typically request 5-8 negative items but at Odigo Real Estate Club, we typically request 20+ items knowing that the seller will likely just give a big credit or discount or fix 30-50% of the items. 

Common Misconceptions

Contingent listings are a critical aspect of real estate transactions, often managed through the multiple listing service, yet they are often misunderstood. Misconceptions about contingencies can lead to unnecessary stress and missed opportunities for both buyers and sellers. Let’s debunk some of the most common contingencies and myths and provide clarity on how contingencies truly function.

Misconception 1: Contingent Listings Are Not Serious Offers

Many believe that contingent offers indicate a lack of seriousness from buyers. This couldn’t be further from the truth. In reality, contingent offers often come from highly motivated buyers who want to ensure that their purchase is sound and secure. These buyers are simply protecting their interests, which is a wise move in any significant financial transaction. According to a Local Leader article, a substantial percentage of real estate transactions include contingencies, reflecting their importance and commonality in the industry.

Misconception 2: Contingencies Always Lead to Failed Deals

While it’s true that contingencies can introduce additional steps in the transaction process, they don’t inherently lead to failed deals. In fact, contingencies often help identify and resolve issues early on, preventing bigger problems down the line. Properly managed contingencies can facilitate smoother transactions by addressing potential deal-breakers upfront, ensuring that both parties are satisfied before finalizing the sale.

Misconception 3: Only Buyers Benefit from Contingencies

Contingencies are not solely beneficial to buyers; sellers can also gain significant advantages. For instance, a home sale contingency can provide sellers with the flexibility to find their next home without the pressure of immediate relocation. Additionally, contingencies can weed out non-serious buyers, as those willing to agree to and fulfill contingency requirements are typically more committed to the transaction.

Misconception 4: Contingencies Complicate the Selling Process

Some sellers might fear that contingencies will overly complicate the selling process, leading to delays and hassles. However, with proper communication and effective management, contingencies can be navigated smoothly. Sellers can work with their real estate agents to set clear expectations and timelines for contingencies, ensuring that both parties understand and agree on the conditions from the outset.

Misconception 5: All Contingencies Are the Same

Not all contingencies are created equal. Each type of contingency serves a specific purpose and offers different protections. For example, a financing contingency is vastly different from an inspection contingency in terms of what it covers and how it impacts the transaction. Understanding the nuances of each type of contingency can help buyers and sellers make informed decisions and negotiate effectively.

Misconception 6: Contingent Listings Are Less Competitive

It’s a common belief that contingent listings are less competitive and therefore less likely to attract multiple offers. While it’s true that some buyers and agents may shy away from contingent listings, a well-priced and desirable property can still generate significant interest. Moreover, buyers who are willing to accommodate contingencies might be more flexible in other areas, such as price or closing date, making them attractive to sellers.

Misconception 7: Contingencies Are Always Enforced Rigidly

Contingencies can be negotiated and modified to suit the needs of both parties. For instance, if a buyer’s financing is delayed but still progressing, a seller might agree to extend the financing contingency period rather than canceling the deal. Flexibility and open communication are key to successfully navigating contingencies and ensuring that both parties feel comfortable moving forward.

Final Thoughts

Understanding contingencies in real estate is crucial for first-time buyers and sellers, especially in today’s competitive market. While the term “contingent” might initially seem daunting, these conditions are designed to protect all parties involved, ensuring that transactions proceed smoothly and fairly. By now, you should have a clearer picture of what contingent listings entail, the types of contingencies commonly used, and the pros and cons they present.

For buyers, contingencies offer essential safeguards. They provide the flexibility needed to address potential issues without being locked into a contract prematurely. From securing financing to ensuring the property meets your expectations through inspections, contingencies are your safety net. However, it’s important to approach them with a strategic mindset. Be specific and clear about your conditions, and communicate effectively with your seller's real estate agent to ensure everything is managed within the stipulated timeframes.

Sellers, on the other hand, can benefit from understanding how contingencies work and negotiating terms that align with their needs. While contingent offers may introduce some uncertainty, they also attract serious buyers who are committed to the process. By setting clear expectations and being prepared to address issues promptly, sellers can navigate contingencies effectively, ensuring a smooth transaction.

The misconceptions surrounding contingencies often stem from a lack of understanding. By debunking these myths, we see that contingencies, rather than being obstacles, are vital components of a well-rounded real estate strategy. They ensure that both buyers and sellers are protected, promoting transparency and fairness in transactions.

At Odigo Real Estate Club, we believe in empowering our clients with knowledge and expertise. Whether you’re buying your first home or selling a property, understanding common real estate contingencies will help you make informed decisions. Our team is here to guide you through every step, ensuring that your real estate journey is as smooth and successful as possible.

Remember, contingencies are not just technicalities—they are crucial tools that can make or break a deal. By approaching them with a clear understanding and strategic planning, you can navigate the real estate market with confidence and achieve your goals. If you have any questions or need personalized advice, don’t hesitate to reach out to us at Odigo Real Estate Club. We’re here to help you every step of the way.

‍